The obsession with VO2 max ignores people like yogis or centenarians who thrive without ever chasing aerobic peaks.

How can something that we can change dramatically in short span be a marker of longevity? Are we saying that a runner is healthier than a non-runner? Because a runner will have a higher VO2 max by default?

I beg to differ on this and here is my argument.

Rethinking VO2 Max as the Best Health Marker: Why It Might Not Be the Ultimate Indicator of Longevity

In recent years, there has been a growing consensus in the scientific and fitness communities that VO2 max is one of the most reliable markers of health and longevity. This measure, which refers to the maximum amount of oxygen your body can utilize during intense exercise, has long been associated with cardiovascular fitness and overall well-being. While there’s no doubt that VO2 max plays a role in assessing cardiovascular health, the idea that it is the “best” or ultimate indicator of health and longevity is oversimplified and, frankly, misguided.

The Case Against VO2 Max as the Best Marker of Longevity

VO2 max is often praised for its association with lower risks of chronic diseases like heart disease, diabetes, and hypertension. Higher VO2 max levels are linked to better cardiovascular efficiency, and it’s believed that maintaining a higher VO2 max could help delay the onset of age-related decline. But what’s often overlooked is that VO2 max can be improved relatively quickly, in a matter of weeks, through targeted exercise. This raises a critical question: Can something that can be changed so rapidly really be a reliable marker of long-term health or longevity?

Question: Yogis can perform rapid inhalations and exhalations (a breathing technique called Kapalbhati) for extended periods, demonstrating remarkable respiratory endurance. Yet, they may not be able to run long distances, which could translate into a relatively low VO₂ max on a treadmill test.

But does that mean their heart is weak? Not necessarily.

This highlights an important distinction: the way we measure VO₂ max primarily reflects one dimension of cardiovascular fitness. It doesn’t necessarily capture the entire picture of heart health.

Personally, and I know many may disagree with me, I believe one of the most meaningful indicators of cardiovascular health should be heart rate recovery (HRR) – how quickly your heart rate returns towards its resting level after exertion..

VO₂ max primarily measures maximum aerobic performance, making it particularly relevant for athletes, but it doesn’t tell the whole story of heart health for the average person.

For most people, especially after 60, heart rate recovery may be a more meaningful indicator of how efficiently the heart supports everyday life.

1. Fitness vs. Long-Term Health

While VO2 max is a great reflection of someone’s current cardiovascular fitness, it doesn’t tell us much about their long-term health trajectory. The fact that VO2 max can be influenced by short-term changes in activity levels or exercise programs means that it’s not as stable or reliable as a measure of long-term health. Someone can improve their VO2 max in a matter of weeks through intense aerobic training, but does that really equate to better health or a longer life? Not necessarily.

Example & Question: You give me a 70 year old student. I make him/her train in the field for couple of weeks. What do you think their VO2 max test would reflect?

Improvement. Right.

But does that mean I have increased their lifespan or heart health for longer term in just 2 weeks? Nope…I just warmed up their heart health. After this they need what we call ‘periodisation’ – changing stimulus that keep challenging their body steadily and build their capacity. So its not VO2 max you see…

2. A Snapshot, Not a Long-Term Indicator

VO2 max gives a snapshot of your fitness at a particular point in time. But here’s the thing: it’s just a snapshot. A low VO2 max at the start of the month doesn’t mean a person is destined for poor health or shorter life expectancy. With a few weeks of exercise, that person can increase their VO2 max significantly. The real question, however, is how consistently someone maintains good cardiovascular health over the long term. It’s the long-term trends, not the short-term fluctuations, that matter when assessing longevity.

Additionally, VO2 max primarily reflects peak performance during intense exercise, which may not be representative of the body’s efficiency during everyday activities

Health Should Be More Than Just VO2 Max?

It’s essential to consider that health isn’t simply about VO2 max. Many individuals who don’t engage in high-intensity training or running live long, healthy lives. A person who eats a balanced diet, manages stress effectively, gets enough sleep, and stays active in other ways (like walking or doing moderate exercise) can be just as healthy as someone who regularly trains for endurance sports.

Several factors contribute to health and longevity beyond VO2 max, including:

  • Genetics: Some people are naturally predisposed to excellent cardiovascular health, even without extensive physical training.
  • Diet and Lifestyle: Regular physical activity (even low-intensity), a balanced diet, mental well-being, and stress management play significant roles in overall health.
  • Metabolic Health: Health metrics like blood pressure, cholesterol, and blood sugar are just as critical to long-term health.
  • Musculoskeletal Health: Strength, flexibility, and mobility are vital for healthy aging.
  • Mind health: Anybody who stays calm and composed generally lives later half of their life with low hear rate.

Focusing too heavily on VO2 max overlooks the broader picture of what contributes to overall health. VO2 max is one piece of the puzzle, but it’s far from the whole picture.

The Trend of Over-Specialization in Health Metrics

There’s a trend in the scientific community to focus on specific health metrics, whether it’s VO2 max, strength, or other single factors, while downplaying others. For example, in recent years, strength training became the center of attention for its ability to prevent muscle loss, improve bone density, and support metabolic health. Now, VO2 max has taken the spotlight due to its association with cardiovascular health and longevity. These trends often make it seem as though these factors are the only indicators of health, but they aren’t. Scientists & studies only explain us how they are related to health but calling it a best predictor of health is a bit of a stretch in my point of view.

Why VO2 Max Isn’t a Complete Measure of Health

VO2 max is certainly useful for understanding someone’s cardiovascular fitness, but it’s a narrow measure. It doesn’t account for all the other aspects of health that are critical for longevity, such as:

  • Mental health and emotional well-being
  • Musculoskeletal integrity
  • Nutritional status
  • Hormonal balance

A person with a lower VO2 max, but who is actively maintaining good metabolic health, managing stress, and eating a nutrient-dense diet, can still be extremely healthy. On the other hand, a runner with a high VO2 max might still face health issues related to overtraining, mental health struggles, or other conditions that don’t relate to cardiovascular fitness.

The Danger of Over-Focusing on One Metric

Relying too heavily on any one fitness or health metric can be problematic. Health is multi-dimensional, and no single measure can capture the full spectrum of a person’s well-being. By focusing too much on VO2 max, we risk neglecting other crucial factors like strength, musculoskeletal health, mental health, and the importance of a balanced, sustainable lifestyle.

If not VO2 max then what could be a reliable marker for longevity? Could it be testosterone? Let’s see if I can make a valid argument

Conclusion: Health Is More Than VO₂ Max

VO₂ max is an important measure of aerobic capacity, but it is not a standalone measure of heart health or longevity. A person can have an excellent VO₂ max and still have coronary artery disease or other underlying health risks.

For the general population, particularly as we age, we should look beyond maximum performance and consider heart rate recovery, resting heart rate, functional capacity, metabolic health, muscle strength, nutrition and hormonal health.

I’m particularly interested in whether VO₂ at rest and during low-intensity activities (oxygen cost of everyday living) could offer additional insights into physiological efficiency and long-term health.

Ultimately, longevity is a systems issue, not a single-number achievement. The goal isn’t simply to build a body that performs exceptionally at its maximum, but one that functions efficiently, remains resilient and supports a healthy life for as long as possible.